Study: Red Light Cameras Increase Crashes

March 13, 2008

Here’s some interesting news I kind of saw coming. Where I live, some traffic lights are equipped with Red Light Cameras. These cameras automatically photograph the license plate of drivers who run the red light. This seems like a great idea, but perhaps not.

These Red Light Camera equipped intersections have signs warning drivers of the camera’s presence. The general idea is this: Drivers are more careful to avoid running the red light. And, if they do…. a camera snaps their license plate and the image is sent to a server. This license plate’s text (letters and numbers) is extracted from the image using some combination of human reading, and automated optical recognition (a computer extracts characters using optical algorithms). Then… the owner of the vehicle receives a Traffic Ticket in the mail for their red light offense. Cha-ching!

Seems like a good idea because red lights are less often run, right? And, red light accidents also occur less often, right?

A recent study by the University Of South Florida College Of Public Health shows that red light cameras actually increase the number of red light accidents, and their severity. Why? Because drivers are more likely to slam on their breaks to avoid running a yellow light. I also imagine in some cases drivers are more likely to speed way up, to avoid running the red light.

So, these cameras cause an interesting phenomenon: This system of automatic red light ticketing causes people to artificially increase the importance not being in the intersection when the light turns red. I say “artificially”, because the most significant real-life priority is to avoid accidents. But, the presence of these cameras causes people to shut off the real-life priority (avoid accidents) and ignore their real-life situations (other drivers in their vicinity)…. all to avoid running the red light.

I consider cell phone related accidents very similar in nature. Drivers talking on cell phones more likely ignore their surroundings because they’ve artificially increased the importance of something else: their cell phone. This is why areas have started banning cell phone usage while driving.

Some areas, such as Florida, are now banning these red light cameras. And as reality shows, I think these cameras should be banned. But these cameras are widely used, and some areas earn sizable profits via this automated ticketing scheme. San Diego, in particular, has made $30 million in 18 months. Hopefully governments will make the right choice, and forgo the easy money – It just doesn’t seem right to profit by harming people, especially your own citizens. Right?

Toms Hardware: Red Light Cameras Increase Crashes And Insurance Rates – Study

Here’s the full study: Red Light Running Cameras: Would Crashes, Injuries and Automobile Insurance Rates Increase If They Are Used in Florida?


Vista Usability (Drivers) II

March 10, 2008

A class action lawsuit is currently ongoing against Microsoft regarding Vista. This lawsuit addresses user experiences with Vista, and how Microsoft misled consumers with cleaver/dishonest marketing.

Here’s where it gets interesting: Bundles of internal Microsoft email have been released to the public, and going by their content: Microsoft executives were aware of Vista problems, dismayed by marketing spin, and upset with: compatibility, drivers, performance, and the final product.

I’ve read through some of this email, and I saw surprisingly negative statements by Microsoft leaders on their Vista experiences. They were confused why Vista didn’t work better (as was/am I), and vocally critical of it. It makes me wonder how these highly paid, experienced and prominent leaders ended up with the product they did. It also makes me ask: Is anyone driving the bus?

Here’s a better summary then I’ve written: The New York Times: They Criticized Vista. And They Should Know

If you want to read the emails, check ‘em out: http://blog.seattlepi.nwsource.com/microsoft/library/vistaexhibitsone.pdf

Here’s Part 1 of my Vista Usability (Drivers) rant http://dataland.wordpress.com/2007/12/10/vista-usability-drivers/


Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.